Selecting the appropriate legal structure is essential when starting a business. LLCs and S Corps are two common business entity choices that offer liability protection, yet they differ in terms of taxation.
In this article, we’ll explain the differences between LLC vs. S Corp in tax terms to help you decide which structure is best for your business. Let’s get started!
What is a Limited Liability Company
Have you ever asked yourself, “What is an LLC?” A Limited Liability Company (LLC) is a type of business structure that offers limited liability protection to its owners while also providing the flexibility of a partnership. Although there are various types of small business LLC structures, they all share the same fundamental advantages.
Learning how to create an LLC can benefit business owners from tax and liability benefits. The small business owners of limited liability companies are called members and are not personally responsible for the company’s debts or legal issues.
What is an S Corporation?
S Corporations (S Corps) are business structures that combine a corporation’s liability protection with a partnership’s tax benefits.
The profits and losses of an S Corp are passed through to the shareholders, who report them on their individual tax returns.
Benefits of an S Corp vs an LLC
Understanding the differences between S Corps and LLCs is crucial in choosing the right legal structure for your business.
This section will explore the pros and cons of an LLC and S Corp to help you make an informed decision.
S Corp Benefits
S Corps offers several benefits that make it an attractive legal structure for many businesses. Below are the main S Corporation benefits to consider:
- Limited Liability: S Corps provides limited liability protection to their owners, which means that shareholders are not personally responsible for the company’s debts or legal issues.
- Tax Benefits: S Corps offers several tax benefits, including the ability to avoid double taxation and the opportunity to save on self-employment tax.
- Professional Image: Choosing an S Corp can give a business a more professional image and help to establish credibility with potential customers, clients, and investors.
- Easy Transfer of Ownership: S Corps offers more flexibility when transferring ownership than other legal structures, making it easier to sell or transfer the business.
- Increased Credibility with Investors: S Corps are subject to stricter regulations than other business structures, which can increase their credibility with investors and lenders.
LLC Benefits
LLCs offer many benefits as well. Below are the main advantages of choosing an LLC:
- Flexible Taxation: LLCs offer flexible taxation options, including the option to be taxed as a sole proprietorship, partnership, S Corp, or C Corp.
- Limited Liability Protection: LLCs provide limited personal liability protection of personal assets to their owners, which means that members are not personally responsible for the company’s debts or legal issues.
- Simplicity: LLCs are relatively easy to set up and maintain compared to other legal structures, such as an S corporation or a C corporation.
- Pass-Through Taxation: LLCs offer pass-through taxation, which means that company profits and losses are passed through to the owners and reported on their personal tax returns.
- Fewer Formalities: LLCs have fewer formalities and requirements than other business structures, making them a more flexible and streamlined option for some businesses.
Disadvantages of an S Corp vs an LLC
S Corps and LLCs also have their disadvantages. Let’s take a look at them below…
S Corp Disadvantages
Although S Corps provides numerous benefits, there are also potential drawbacks to keep in mind. Here are the primary disadvantages associated with selecting an S Corp:
- Stricter Regulations: S Corps are subject to stricter regulations than other business structures, which can increase administrative burden and costs.
- Limitations on Shareholders: S Corps can have a maximum of 100 shareholders, and all must be U.S. citizens or residents. This restriction can hinder capital-raising efforts and make it difficult to attract investors.
- Complexity of Taxation: While S Corps offers tax benefits, the taxation process can be complex and requires careful planning and record-keeping to ensure compliance.
- Costs of Incorporation and Maintenance: Setting up and maintaining an S Corp can be more expensive and time-consuming than other legal structures.
- Potential for Loss of S Corp Status: S Corp must meet several requirements to maintain their status, and failure to meet these requirements can result in loss of S Corp status and its tax benefits.
LLC Disadvantages
LLCs also have some potential downsides to consider. Below are the main disadvantages of choosing an LLC:
- Self-Employment Income Taxes: LLC members may have to pay self-employment tax, which can be higher than the payroll taxes paid by S Corp shareholders.
- Limited Life: LLCs have a limited lifespan and can be dissolved if a member dies or leaves the company.
- Less Established: LLCs are a newer legal structure and may not have the same level of recognition or credibility as other business structures.
- Management Issues: LLCs can face management issues if there is a disagreement among members or if one member takes on a larger workload than others.
- Potential Personal Liability: While LLCs offer liability protection, members may still be personally liable if they engage in fraudulent or illegal activities.
S Corp vs. LLC Taxes
In this section, we’ll compare S Corp vs LLC taxes to help you understand the potential tax implications of each structure.
S Corp Taxes
S Corps offers unique tax advantages compared to other business structures. Here are the main tax rules for S Corps:
- Pass-Through Taxation: S Corps are pass-through entities, meaning that the company’s profits and losses pass through to the shareholders and are reported when business owners pay personal income tax.
- Salary Requirements: S Corp shareholders must receive a reasonable salary, which is subject to payroll taxes, but the remaining profits can be distributed as dividends and won’t carry a requirement to pay self-employment taxes.
- Shareholder Limits: S Corps have limitations on the number and type of shareholders that can participate in the company.
- Single Taxation: S Corp taxable income only gets taxed once, at the shareholder level, whereas other business structures may face double taxation at both the corporate income tax and personal income tax level.
- Retained Earnings: S Corps can retain earnings for future business needs, but excessive retained earnings may result in penalties.
LLC Taxes
LLCs offer flexible tax options for business owners. Here are the main rules for LLC taxes:
- Pass-Through Taxation: LLCs are also pass-through entities, meaning that the company’s profits and losses pass through to the owners and are reported on their individual tax returns.
- Self-Employment Taxes: LLC owners are subject to self-employment taxes on all business income, including profits that are not distributed as salary.
- Flexible Taxation: LLCs have the option to be taxed as a sole proprietorship, partnership, or corporation, allowing them to tailor their tax structure to the specific needs of the business and its owners.
- No Shareholder Limits: LLCs do not have limitations on the number or type of owners who can participate in the company.
- State Taxes: Depending on the state where they are registered and operate, LLCs might be liable for state-level taxes.
Why would a business owner choose an S corporation instead of an LLC?
Business owners may choose an S Corp instead of an LLC because of its tax advantages.
S Corps offers the opportunity to avoid paying self-employment tax on a portion of the business’s profits, which can result in significant tax savings for the business owner.
Which is better for self-employment tax, an LLC or an S-corp?
S Corps are generally better for self-employment tax because they allow business owners to pay themselves a salary and take a distribution of profits, which can result in significant savings on self-employment tax.
Which is cheaper, an LLC or an S-corp?
In terms of formation costs, LLCs are generally cheaper than S Corps. However, S Corps can offer tax advantages that may ultimately make them more cost-effective for business owners.
Can a single-member LLC be an S-corp?
A single-member LLC can elect to be taxed as an S Corp by filing Election by a Small Business Corporation Form 2553 with the Internal Revenue Service.
However, there are specific requirements that must be met in order to qualify for S Corp status.
Which is better, an LLC or an S Corp?
The decision between an LLC and an S Corp ultimately depends on the specific needs and goals of the business owner. Before getting started, research the benefits of each within your specific industry. For example, you may ask yourself, “Should freelancers establish themselves as LLC companies?”
Both structures offer liability protection, but S Corps may offer tax advantages that make them more attractive for certain businesses.
Image: Envato Elements
